Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Timms's avatar

When I read "it is irrefutable that the trillion dollars of post-war aid have done more harm than good", I immediately thought of the book "Factfulness" by Hans Rosling (2018). Factfulness will certainly try to refute that aid generally does more harm than good.

I haven't read Dead Aid so perhaps I am inadvertently straw-manning its argument, but it is not true to say all poverty levels are escalating. In 2002, 26% of people in the world lived in extreme poverty. In 2022, only 8.3% did.

"Factfulness" isn't seeking to justify aid programs blindly. Rather, the reader comes away knowing that at least some aid must be working- the world writ large is getting better (life expectancy, income, education) though perhaps we don't feel it in the wealthy world. The efficiency certainly can improve, but retrenchment isn't the answer. https://a.co/d/1rBWm2X

A book suggestion on the nuclear theme, you may enjoy "The 2020 Commission Report on the North Korean Nuclear Attacks Against the United States: A Speculative Novel" by Jeffrey Lewis (2018). Lewis is a nonproliferation academic, so though it's fiction, it is highly informed. https://a.co/d/12PP8t8

Expand full comment
frederic boulanger's avatar

Thanks for the recommendations at large. I picked up Rob Lowe’s. I enjoyed it. Young blood didn't disappoint. Felt I was living the 80ies through his stories again. I would not have picked it up had you not shared it so enthousiastically. Best wishes cheers

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts